|
Spring 2003 An Adirondack Woodswoman Tells Her Tale Adirondack author and ecologist Anne LaBastille has a good story- she's just not sure how to tell it.
In 1954, after divorcing
her husband, Ms. LaBastille bought a twenty-acre plot of private land
in the Adirondacks. With the help of local craftsman, she built a crude
log cabin by hand on the shore of what her memoir terms "Black
Bear Lake." Devoid of indoor plumbing and electricity, and accessible
only by boat or hiking trail, the cabin became her new home. Woodswoman
is the story of Anne LaBastille's life alone in the wilderness. It's a compelling yarn-
who hasn't dreamt of forsaking the hassles of modern society and adopting
a completely hermetic lifestyle, with only stoic pines and lively wildlife
for company? Unfortunately, Ms. LaBastille's ability to tell a good
story is considerably less than her ability to build a log cabin; the
construction of which, incidentally, is relayed in such grueling finite
detail at the beginning of the book it makes you want to put it down
before it even gets going. If you stick it out you
find that the rest of the memoir proceeds in a similarly tedious fashion.
Parts of Ms. LaBastille's story are undeniably interesting, particularly
to readers who are familiar with the landscape and local character she
describes. She is apparently incapable of teasing out what is interesting
from the irrelevant minutiae of everyday life. The incidents she details
that would capture a reader's attention- violent winter storms, threatening
trespassers, lost tourists, and rapacious wildlife- are buried within
a rambling reconstruction of Anne LaBastille's every thought and move
since she set foot in the Adirondack wilderness. To further complicate
things, data about the Adirondack land and its history are interspersed
at seemingly random intervals throughout the book; while one paragraph
may read like an entry from a compulsively detailed journal, the next
reads like a textbook. Many reviewers have hailed
Ms. LaBastille's bestselling memoir-trilogy (soon to be four, with the
self-publication of Woodswoman IV) as the female response to Thoreau's
famous wilderness chronicle, Walden. While you can't help but applaud
the stamina and verve of a woman who lives alone in the wild, Anne LaBastille's
similarity to Thoreau ends there. While Walden is a poignant, deftly
crafted meditation on man's position in both the natural and the metaphysical
universe, Woodswoman is primarily a meditation on the author herself,
from what she ate for breakfast to the time of night she went to bed.
If the point of memoir is to allow readers access to the author's unique
human experience, Woodswoman certainly does its job. It does it so well
in fact, you'll forget why you were interested in the first place.
|
|